The Most Affordable Insurers for Recent Grads

What are the Affordable Insurers for Recent Grads? For recent college graduates, the freedom and excitement of starting a new chapter can quickly give way to the realities of managing personal finances. One significant expense that often catches new grads off guard is the cost of car insurance.  

Affordable Insurers for Recent Grads

With rates notoriously higher for drivers under 25, finding an affordable policy can be a daunting task. However, with a little knowledge and strategic approach, recent grads can navigate the auto insurance landscape and secure cost-effective coverage. 

Key Takeaways: 

  • Comparison shopping is crucial for finding the best rates tailored to your unique situation. 
  • Opting for higher deductibles and bundling policies can lead to substantial savings. 
  • Maintaining a good credit score and exploring telematics programs can also help reduce premiums. 
  • Consider staying on a parent’s policy or updating coverage when moving to a new state. 

The Most Affordable Insurers for Recent Grads 

According to research by The Zebra, certain insurance companies consistently offer more competitive rates for drivers aged 22-25, the typical age range for recent graduates. Here are the top 10 most affordable options based on average annual premiums: 

Rank  Company  Average Annual Premium 
1  USAA*  $1,730 
2  GEICO  $1,867 
3  Nationwide  $1,947 
4  State Farm  $2,111 
5  21st Century  $2,217 
6  Farmers  $2,276 
7  Progressive  $2,384 
8  Amica Mutual  $2,519 
9  Auto Club  $2,580 
10  Allstate  $3,084 

*USAA is only available to active and former military members and their families. 

It’s important to note that these figures are averages, and your actual rates may vary based on factors such as: 

  • Your driving record 
  • Location 
  • Credit score 
  • The type of vehicle you drive 

Strategies for Saving on Car Insurance as a Recent Grad 

While shopping around for quotes from multiple insurers is a crucial first step, there are several other strategies recent grads can employ to keep their auto insurance costs in check: 

  1. Bundle Your Policies

Many insurance companies offer discounts when you bundle multiple policies, such as auto and renters insurance. On average, bundling can save you up to 25% on your premiums, making it a financially savvy move for recent grads who may also be in need of renters coverage. 

  • For example, Geico advertises bundling discounts of up to 25% when you combine renters and auto policies. 
  1. Increase Your Deductible
  • A higher deductible means you’ll pay more out of pocket if you need to file a claim, but it can also significantly lower your monthly premiums. 
  • According to Consumer Reports, increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 could save you up to 25% on your insurance costs. 
  1. Explore Telematics Programs

Telematics, or usage-based insurance programs, use in-vehicle devices or mobile apps to monitor your driving habits and adjust your rates accordingly. Safe driving practices can earn you substantial discounts, making telematics an attractive option for recent grads who may not have an extensive driving history. 

  1. Maintain a Good Credit Score

While it may seem counterintuitive, your credit score is one of the factors insurance companies consider when setting your rates. Drivers with poor credit typically pay higher premiums, so it’s essential for recent grads to establish and maintain good credit habits early on. 

  • A study by Consumer Reports found that drivers with poor credit scores could pay over $1,000 more per year for auto insurance compared to those with excellent credit. 
  1. Consider Dropping Comprehensive and Collision Coverage

If you’re driving an older vehicle with a low market value, it may not make financial sense to carry comprehensive and collision coverage. These optional coverages protect your vehicle in the event of an accident or other damage, but the premiums can be costly if your vehicle is worth less than a few thousand dollars. 

  • As a general guideline, NerdWallet recommends dropping these coverages once your vehicle’s value dips below $4,000. 

Additional Considerations for Recent Grads 

Moving to a New State 

If your post-graduation plans involve relocating to a different state, it’s crucial to update your auto insurance policy accordingly. Insurance regulations and rates vary from state to state, so you’ll need to obtain a new policy that meets the requirements of your new residence. 

  • ValuePenguin provides a helpful state-by-state guide on updating your auto insurance when moving. 

Additionally, you’ll need to update your driver’s license and vehicle registration with the new state’s DMV within a specified timeframe, typically 30-60 days after your move. 

  • Most states, like California, require new residents to transfer their out-of-state license within 10-30 days. 

Staying on a Parent’s Policy 

In some cases, recent grads may have the option to remain on their parent’s auto insurance policy, at least temporarily. However, this is generally only possible if you still reside at the same address as your parents and your vehicle is primarily garaged there. 

  • Insurance companies base their rates on the vehicle’s garaging address, so moving out and taking your car with you will likely require obtaining your own separate policy. 
  • Bankrate recommends getting your own policy once you move out or turn 26, whichever comes first. 

Here are 4 FAQs that could be added to the article: 


  1. Can I stay on my parent’s auto insurance policy after graduating?

In some cases, yes – it may be possible to remain on your parent’s policy temporarily after graduating college. However, this is typically only allowed if you still reside at the same address as your parents and your vehicle is primarily garaged there. Insurance rates are based on the vehicle’s garaging location, so moving out on your own will likely require obtaining a separate policy. 

  1. How much can I expect to pay for car insurance as a recent grad?

According to research cited in the article, average annual premiums for recent grads aged 22-25 can range from around $1,700 (USAA for military) up to over $3,000 (Allstate). However, rates vary significantly based on factors like your driving record, location, credit score, and the insurer. Shopping around and comparing quotes is crucial to find your best rate. 

  1. Is it worth dropping comprehensive and collision coverage for an older car?

If your vehicle is worth less than around $4,000, it may not make financial sense to carry comprehensive and collision coverage. These optional protections can get expensive when the cost of premiums approaches or exceeds your vehicle’s value. However, dropping them means you won’t have coverage if your vehicle is damaged or totaled, so weigh the risks carefully. 

  1. How much can bundling policies save me on car insurance?

Most major insurers offer bundling discounts when you combine policies like auto and renters insurance. The potential savings can be significant – the article cites estimates that bundling can lead to discounts of up to 25% on your premiums compared to carrying the policies separately with different providers.


As a recent college graduate, navigating the world of auto insurance can seem overwhelming, especially when faced with the notoriously higher rates for young drivers. However, by employing strategies like: 

  • Comparison shopping 
  • Bundling policies 
  • Increasing deductibles 
  • Exploring telematics programs 

You can significantly reduce your insurance costs. 

Remember, your circumstances are unique, so it’s essential to shop around and carefully evaluate your coverage needs and budget constraints. With a little effort and research, you can find an affordable car insurance policy that provides the protection you need without breaking the bank. 

Previous article7 Reasons Flying Business Class Is Worth the Points 
Next articleAuto Insurance Considerations for Remote Workers: Factors to Consider 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here